Intel · Preconstruction & estimating
Preconstruction and estimating hiring.
Preconstruction is where a contractor decides what it is willing to be held to. The people in these seats set the number the business is judged on, and they do it before there is a project to point at.
These notes cover what the seat actually owns, how to read a candidate who has only ever estimated in one delivery method, and why an estimating hire fails more often on judgment than on arithmetic.
Searches we run in this discipline
Selah Talent Partners runs confidential executive search for mandates that cannot be publicly posted.
68 articles
Careers
Going independent as a construction estimator: what a one-person practice runs on
Going independent as a construction estimator trades a salary for a sales pipeline. The hours, tax, covenants and clients decide whether it works.
Hiring
Hiring a CMGC preconstruction manager: the price is negotiated against the owner's estimate
Under CMGC the contractor prices in open-book rounds against a blind agency estimate. The seat needs a negotiator, not a hard-bid closer.
Hiring
Hiring a mass timber preconstruction manager: buying a structure few estimators have priced
Mass timber can be faster and lower-carbon at no premium, if someone who has bought it makes the fabricator, code and MEP calls early.
Hiring
Hiring an industrial construction estimator: pricing in craft hours, not square feet
An industrial estimate is a labor model. What the estimator builds, from unit man-hours to productivity factors, and how to test the build-up.
Market Intelligence
What an architect sees in a contractor preconstruction team during design development
Allowance counts, reconciliation and who attends: what a CM-at-risk preconstruction team shows the architect at design development.
Hiring
Who owns the construction cost database: the estimating seat that turns finished jobs into new bids
Two estimators, one cost database, two different numbers. Why field cost codes break historical cost data, and who should own the fix.
Hiring
Hiring a homebuilder purchasing director: the house cost is set before the first start
In production homebuilding the cost of a house is fixed in purchasing before the first footing is dug. What the seat owns, and how to test for it.
Hiring
Hiring a multifamily preconstruction manager for a developer-builder: pricing to the pro forma
A developer-builder's preconstruction manager prices to the pro forma, not the drawings. Why an estimator is the wrong hire, and how to find the right one.
Careers
Leaving a contractor for a construction technology company: what an estimator trades
Why construction software firms recruit estimators and project managers, how their pay and equity work, and what you give up leaving a contractor.
Careers
Moving into preconstruction as a project manager: what the front end of the job pays for
Why project managers move into preconstruction, what field experience is worth before bid day, what it lacks, and how the pay compares.
Hiring
The estimating exercise in a preconstruction leader interview
How to build a short, fair estimating exercise for a chief estimator or preconstruction finalist, what to score, and what never to ask for.
Careers
Estimator to business development: you already speak the owner's language, now learn to lose
Why estimators make credible construction business development leaders, why many struggle, and what to test before you move.
Careers
From preconstruction manager to preconstruction director: what changes
A preconstruction director owns pursuit strategy, go/no-go, team capacity and the handoff to operations. The evidence firms want, and how to build it.
Hiring
Verifying a chief estimator's hit rate before you hire
A chief estimator's hit rate means nothing without its denominator, its mix and the margin the wins carried. How to check all three before the offer.
Compensation
Vice president of preconstruction compensation: how to set the package
No public survey reliably prices a VP of preconstruction. Anchor the base on federal wage data, then pay the incentive on hit rate and closeout margin.
Hiring
Outsourced construction estimating: what a takeoff service buys, and what bid day still needs
An outside estimating service buys quantity capacity. It does not buy the judgment that sets the number on bid day. Here is how to split the two.
Careers
The chief estimator career path: the chair goes to the estimator who stops estimating
What separates a senior estimator from a chief estimator, the experience that gets you the chair, and when moving firms is the faster route.
Careers
The construction estimator resume: the number you know about yourself and never write down
An estimator resume is screened on bid volume, delivery method, what you priced yourself and a hit rate with its denominator. Software is a footnote.
Careers
Estimator to project manager: you priced the job, now run the part you left out
Why contractors want a project manager who can price, what estimating does not teach about running work, and the bridge roles that get you there.
Careers
From hard-bid to negotiated estimating: the same takeoff, a different job
Negotiated estimating prices a building before it is drawn and defends the number for a year. What a hard-bid estimator has to learn to make the move.
Hiring
The remote construction estimator: which parts of the job travel and which do not
Takeoff and pricing travel. Sub relationships and bid day do not. How to decide whether an estimating seat can be remote, and what the offer should say.
Compensation
Chief estimator compensation: how the pay is built, and what the offer has to carry
Published wage data blends takeoff estimators with the person who signs the bid. How chief estimator pay is built, and why bonus design matters most.
Hiring
Hiring a conceptual estimator: pricing a building before the drawings exist
A conceptual estimator prices scope nobody has drawn yet. Why takeoff skill does not predict it, and an interview exercise that does.
Hiring
Hiring a construction technology director: the job is adoption, and software is the easy part
Most contractors own more software than their people use. What a technology director is for, who should hold the seat, and when not to create it.
Hiring
Hiring a design manager for a design-build contractor: owning design cost before the GMP
On a design-build job the contractor owns the design risk. The design manager is the seat that keeps drawings inside the price. How to hire one.
Hiring
Hiring an MEP estimator at a general contractor: who checks the biggest number in the bid
On technical buildings the mechanical and electrical scope is the largest number in the estimate. Why a general contractor needs its own MEP estimator.
Hiring
The construction slowdown bench: who to keep and who to hire when backlog thins
When backlog thins, the cut that saves the most this quarter is often the seat that wins the next one. A sequence for the bench.
Hiring
How to assess a construction operations and estimating leader
Reference calls confirm what you already believe. Here is what actually separates a strong construction leader from a plausible one.
Market Intelligence
Budgeting for construction leadership turnover cost in preconstruction and project management
Every contractor already pays for leadership turnover. Almost none of them budget for it, which is why it always arrives as a surprise.
Market Intelligence
Construction bench depth: succession planning in preconstruction and project management
Bench depth is what a surety, an owner and a lender all check before they commit. Most contractors can only prove it by naming people who never did the job.
Hiring
Writing a Compensation Philosophy for Construction Operations and Estimating
How contractors set a compensation philosophy that survives a counteroffer, a hot market, and the estimator who finds out what the new hire is paid.
Hiring
The construction hiring brief: define the estimating and project management role before you search
Most failed construction leadership hires trace back to a brief that was never written. Here is what a real one contains.
Hiring
A construction interview scorecard for preconstruction and project management hires
Most construction interviews test rapport and recall. A scorecard tests whether the candidate has carried the work you are about to hand them.
Hiring
What an Unfilled Construction Seat Costs You Every Week It Stays Open
The running cost of an open preconstruction, estimating or project management seat, measured against backlog rather than against the salary you are saving.
Hiring
How to read a construction candidate's backlog claims on a resume
A resume that says $200M of project experience is telling you almost nothing. Here is the question that turns it into information.
Hiring
Hiring a construction bid manager for a hard bid and design-build operation
Bid day fails in the last four hours or it does not fail at all. The manager who owns those hours is rarely the chief estimator.
Hiring
Hiring a construction business development director: the seat that decides what you get to bid
Most contractors hire business development to chase revenue. The seat that works decides which jobs never reach the estimating team.
Hiring
Hiring a construction estimating director: the seat that decides which jobs you never bid
An estimating director is not a senior estimator. The job is deciding what not to bid, and most firms hire for the wrong one.
Hiring
Hiring a construction procurement director for long lead equipment on a GMP project
Switchgear does not care about your schedule. The seat that orders it before the design is finished is the one that saves the job.
Hiring
Hiring a construction purchasing manager: the seat that turns an estimate into commitments
Buyout is where the estimate becomes real money. Most firms treat it as paperwork and lose the margin they bid.
Hiring
In-House Recruiting Function or Search Firm: The Construction Leadership Math
The real cost of an in-house construction recruiting function, measured against what a search firm charges for preconstruction and project management hires.
Hiring
Onboarding a construction leader: the employer's first 100 days
The search ends at the offer. The hire succeeds or fails in the hundred days after it, and most of that is the employer's work, not the new leader's.
Hiring
Replace or coach: deciding on a construction leader who is struggling
The decision to replace a struggling estimating or operations leader is usually made too late, for reasons that have nothing to do with the person.
Hiring
What to expect from a construction search firm before the first interview
The weeks between signing with a search firm and meeting the first candidate are where a search is won or lost. Here is what should be happening.
Market Intelligence
Confidential construction search: what your team should never learn
Most confidential searches are not leaked by the recruiter. They are leaked internally, for good reasons, by people trying to be helpful.
Market Intelligence
Why a construction leadership search fails: the brief nobody wrote
Failed leadership searches in construction almost never fail at sourcing. They fail at the beginning, in a conversation that did not happen.
Market Intelligence
The construction non-compete: what it costs your estimating and project management hiring
A non-compete you would never enforce still shapes who applies, what they cost, and how long the seat stays empty.
Hiring
Design-build construction leadership hiring: why your best hard-bid estimator may struggle
Design-build moves the money decisions upstream into design. The estimator who wins hard-bid work is not automatically the one who wins this.
Market Intelligence
An ESOP transition exposes your bench: construction leadership hiring after the sale
An ESOP buys the founder out over years. It does not buy a second layer of leadership, and the repurchase obligation makes that gap expensive.
Market Intelligence
Hiring a construction buyout director: the seat that keeps or loses the GMP
The estimator sets the GMP. Somebody else decides whether you keep it. In most contractors that person does not have the job title or the authority.
Hiring
Hiring a construction estimating manager: the seat that runs the bid calendar and the estimating bench
An estimating manager decides which bids get the department's best hours and who grows into the next chief estimator. Most briefs hire a senior estimator.
Market Intelligence
Hiring a construction cost escalation lead: pricing risk you cannot see on bid day
Your estimator did not get the price wrong. They got the date wrong. That is a different hire, and most contractors do not make it.
Hiring
Hiring a lean construction and prefabrication leader: the hire that decides whether it sticks
Prefabrication programs fail on organizational resistance, not technology. That makes the leader a change hire, and most briefs screen for the wrong things.
Market Intelligence
Hiring a VDC and BIM leader: the seat between the model and the money
A clash-free model does not make a buildable sequence. Here is what a VDC and BIM leader actually owns, and how to hire one.
Hiring
Hiring an MEP coordination manager: the seat that prices your design-build risk
An MEP coordination manager decides whether your trade conflicts get resolved in the model or in the field. The cost difference is not close.
Hiring
Hiring a hard bid chief estimator, and why negotiated experience does not transfer
A negotiated-work estimator can lose you hard bid jobs by winning them. The two disciplines optimize for opposite outcomes.
Market Intelligence
How a confidential construction search actually runs, week by week
Everyone agrees some searches cannot be posted. Far fewer can describe what replaces the posting, week by week.
Hiring
How long a construction executive search takes, week by week
A confidential construction executive search runs 9 to 14 weeks from kickoff to accepted offer. Here is where the weeks actually go.
Market Intelligence
Your client needs a VP of preconstruction: what to check before referring a construction recruiter
A referral puts your judgment on the line, not the recruiter's. Four checks that hold up when the search goes badly.
Hiring
Replacing a chief estimator who is still in the seat and not leaving voluntarily
The retirement playbook assumes a cooperative handover. When the incumbent is not leaving by choice, every step of it works against you.
Hiring
Hiring a commercial construction estimator: what an estimator recruiter screens for
A shrinking occupation that is the second hardest to fill. Here is why, and what it means for how you screen a commercial estimator.
Hiring
The construction counteroffer trap: why your best candidate accepted and then stayed put
A verbal acceptance is not a hire. Here is why counteroffers work so well in construction, and the five process steps that neutralize them before offer stage.
Hiring
Your chief estimator retires in 18 months. The bid history goes with them
The hardest part of replacing a retiring chief estimator is not finding one. It is that you cannot advertise the role while they are still sitting in it.
Hiring
Confidential construction executive search: replacing a leader who is still in the seat
Some construction roles cannot be advertised because the person in the seat has not been told. Here is how that search actually runs.
Hiring
Construction headhunters, recruiters and search firms: what the difference means for your hire
Three words used interchangeably describe three different contracts. The distinction decides who you actually reach.
Hiring
What construction management recruiters should ask before a preconstruction search
Most preconstruction searches stall on the brief, not the market. Here is what a brief has to specify before sourcing starts.
Hiring
How to choose between construction search firms: the questions that separate them
Every construction search firm says the same things. Six questions expose which ones can actually do the work.
Hiring
What a construction executive search firm actually does, and when you need one
Executive search is a process, not a resume service. Here is what the process involves and when it is worth buying.
Carrying one of these searches?
Send a confidential brief. No approach is made to anyone inside your business without your agreement.
Send a confidential brief